Class actions in labor law
When an employer does not pay a particular right to one employee, it usually does not pay it to other employees either. In such cases a class action can be filed: a single claim submitted on behalf of all the employees harmed by the same violation, including employees who never contacted an attorney and may not even know they were harmed. An individual claim for a few hundred or a few thousand shekels is sometimes not worthwhile. A class action unites all the small claims into one large claim, and the employer is required to pay all the employees.
When can a class action be filed against an employer?
The law permits a class action only in matters specified in it. In labor law, these are the main cases:
- Claims between an employee and an employer arising from an employment relationship (within the jurisdiction of the regional labour court), for example wages, overtime, recuperation pay, pension contributions, redemption of leave and severance pay.
- Minimum wage: a claim by an employee who did not receive the minimum wage.
- The right to work seated and in suitable conditions: for example employees who are not allowed to sit during work.
- Contract workers: claims under the law regulating employment of workers by manpower contractors.
- Discrimination at work: a claim on the grounds of discrimination under the Equal Employment Opportunities Law, or under the Equal Pay for Female and Male Employees Law.
Two important qualifications:
- Delay compensation: in a labor-law class action it is not possible to claim wage-delay compensation, severance-pay delay compensation or allowance-delay compensation. The wages themselves can be claimed.
- Employees under a collective agreement: if a collective agreement regulating the employee's working conditions applies to the employee, and the employer (or an employers' organisation of which the employer is a member) is a party to the agreement, a class action cannot be filed on the grounds in this section — wages, minimum wage, seated work and contract workers.
Examples of violations suitable for a class action
- Overtime: the employer does not pay it, or calculates it by a wrong method for all employees.
- Pension: the employer did not make pension contributions, made them late, or contributed less than required.
- Minimum wage: the employer paid less than the minimum wage.
- Recuperation pay or redemption of leave: the employer did not pay them to employees who finished working.
- Seated work: the employer did not provide seating to employees, for example cashiers or security guards.
- Working time: the employer did not pay for compulsory attendance before the shift, for example a roll call or equipment check.
- Pay gaps: female employees receive lower pay than male employees for the same work.
Who can file?
An employee who has a cause of action of their own can file a motion to certify a class action on behalf of all the employees harmed like them, if the claim raises substantial questions of fact or law common to all. After the court approves the class action, the employee is called the "representative plaintiff", and their attorney is called the "representative counsel".
In certain circumstances an organisation or a public authority may also file.
How does it work? The stages
- Initial check: we examine the payslips, the reports and the contract, and assess whether the violation is shared by additional employees.
- Motion for certification: a motion to approve the claim as a class action is filed with the labour court, together with the statement of claim. For jurisdiction purposes, the amount of the claim is the cumulative amount of the claims of all members of the group.
- Certification stage: the court examines whether there are questions common to all the employees and a reasonable possibility that they will be decided in their favour; whether a class action is the efficient and fair way to decide the dispute; and whether the employees' matter will be represented and managed appropriately and in good faith.
- Management of the claim or settlement: after certification, the proceeding continues on behalf of the whole group. Many proceedings end in a settlement arrangement, which the court must approve.
What happens to employees who did not file the claim?
- They are part of the group: when the court certifies the class action, it defines the group. Everyone who belongs to it is considered to have agreed that the claim be filed on their behalf.
- You can opt out: an employee who does not want to be included in the group may notify the court within 45 days of publication of the certification decision, or by a later date set by the court.
- Who is not included: a person whose cause of action arose after the class action was certified.
Limitation periods: why act early
When the court certifies a class action, all members of the group are treated, for limitation purposes, as if they had filed a claim on the day the motion for certification was filed. Even if the motion is rejected, a group member's limitation period does not end before one year has passed from the day the decision became final — provided that their claim had not expired by the time the motion was filed.
The meaning: the date on which the motion is filed matters. A claim that had already expired before then will not "come back to life".
Settlement: protections for employees
- Every settlement requires court approval.
- A notice is published of the filing of a motion to approve a settlement. Group members may file a reasoned objection within 45 days of publication of the notice, or by a later date set by the court.
- A group member who does not want the settlement to apply to them may ask to opt out of the group to which the settlement will apply, by the same date.
- The court approves a settlement only if it finds that it is fair, reasonable and proper, taking into account the matter of the group members. As a rule, before approval it receives an opinion from an expert examiner in the field.
How do you receive the money?
When the court decides in favour of the group, it may determine how the compensation is distributed, for example:
- payment to each employee whose entitlement was proved;
- an instruction that each employee must prove their entitlement;
- compensation in a lump sum, with a way to calculate each employee's share.
If monetary compensation to group members is impractical, the court may order other relief for the benefit of the group or the public. In a class action, exemplary (punitive) damages are not awarded.
How much does it cost the employee?
In a class action the court sets the attorney's fee, and the attorney cannot receive more than the amount set. If the claim succeeds or ends in a settlement, the court orders payment of an award to the representative plaintiff, unless it finds for special reasons that this is not justified. In setting the award it takes into account, among other things, the effort and risk the plaintiff took on, and the benefit the claim brought to the employees.
Can you "settle" with the employer on the side?
No. A person who filed a motion for certification, the representative plaintiff or the attorney cannot withdraw from the proceeding without court approval, and cannot receive a benefit from the employer in connection with withdrawal without approval. This is a protection for the other employees in the group.
Why the Haim Pechter law office?
- Labor law at the heart of the office: labor law is the office's central field. We know the payslips, the calculations and the sector agreements.
- Experience in class actions: the office files motions for certification of class actions and represents in them.
- Personal attention: Attorney Pechter accompanies the representative plaintiff throughout the proceeding.
Main sources: Employment of Workers by Manpower Contractors Law, 1996 · Class Actions Law, 2006 · Equal Employment Opportunities Law, 1988 · Equal Pay for Female and Male Employees Law, 1996. The information is general and is not legal advice. Each case is examined on its own circumstances.
This page is a translation of the Hebrew page on the site, where the full guides are available. Full guides (Hebrew)
Do you think your employer harmed the rights of many employees?
Leave your details, or call. We will check the payslips and tell you whether there is a class action here.
Sun–Thu 9:00–18:00 · Fri 8:00–12:00